Dolomite Beach walang kuwentang proyekto – Legarda

Mabuti kung ipinasara pero naresolba ang pag baha? Kung ang pag dadaluyan ng untreated water ay di kakayanin ng Water Treatment Plant tuwing may bagyo.

wala naman law na bawal bumaha bossing, ang meron law is a law that bans discharging of untreated water plus nag impose ang court ng obligation to restore the beauty of Manila Bay, the law has nothing to do with flooding at all

If that’s the case, no need mo na pala mag reklamo sa goverment kapag na perperwisyo ka ng baha. At hindi na pala kaylangan masolusyonan yung pag baha, okay lang naman ma perwisyo ka.

Wala naman law nag nag sasabi na bawal bumaha so hindi obligasyon ng gobeyerno na solusyon ang problema sa pag baha.

haha di naman problem ang pagre-reklamo sa gobyerno bossing, yung problema is putting the blame of flooding to something which has nothing to do with it

Hahaha, then as a citizen, don’t blame the government. But the last administration also blame the PNoy administration?

haha i don’t think so since duterte instead continue responding to the court’s order like PNoy admin did, in other words digong actually continued what the PNoy admin did

Same goes with the current administration.

nope, the bangag admin is actually against with the Dolomite project

Not really, the current administration is not against the Dolomite Beach project overall. While MMDA Chairman Don Artes (an appointee under Marcos) has criticized it for contributing to flooding by blocking drainage outfalls, DENR officials have defended the project, attributing floods to climate change and calling for science-based assessments. BBM did not oppose the said project.

take note that both MMDA and DENR are under bangag admin, di pa pina-cancel ang dolomite but bangag jr. is into investigation of the project already, naghahanap na nag justification to close the project

And your assuming it without assurance sinasabi mo?

Reclamation project yan tinutukoy mo, not the Dolomite Beach itself.

tingin mo pag gagawa ka ng artificial beach di ka magre-reclaim bossing? hehe

hindi naman talaga part ng reclamation projects yung Dolomite Beach, kahit na konektado siya sa plano to fix up Manila Bay. Basically, naglagay lang sila ng crushed dolomite sand sa shoreline ng Manila Bay para gawing artificial white-sand beach, pang-beauty at tourism. Eh, yung reclamation projects, iba yun—usually, gumagawa ng bagong lupa by filling up submerged areas with sand, soil, or rocks, like yung 22 reclamation projects sa Manila Bay. Sa Dolomite Beach, wala namang bagong lupa na ginawa; pinaganda lang yung existing shoreline with dolomite sand over a 900-meter stretch, mga 22,000 square meters, kaya hindi naman masyadong na-change yung shape ng bay.

useless pa rin pag talunan natin bossing since both dolomite and other reclamation projects are all responses to the court’s order to restore the beauty of Manila Bay, so kahit pa sabihin nating namimili ang bangag still may pina-imbistigahan pa rin sa compliance ng previous admin

And overall, the primary cause of Flooding in areas like Taft Avenue is the Dolomite Beach Project, as well as the outdated and insufficient drainage and treatment systems. Yung ruling hindi naman talaga ang cause ng flodding. It pressured agencies to act, and their poor execution.

wala namang kinalaman ang dolomite beach sa pagpapasara ng drainage, pinasara ang drainage since it violated the clean water act (RA9275) and it causes more pollution to the bay

Hahaha, kahit anung sabihin mo pang excuse, naka direct link yung mga drainage outfalls sa Dolomite Beach. Kung inuna pa niyang dagdagan at ayusin ang mga flood and water treatment system kaysa sa walang kwentang palamuti na yan, edit sana walang baha ngayon sa Manila at malinis na yung tubig na nilalabas sa Manila Bay.

actually inuna niyang lagyan ng treatment facilities bossing before closure, yung problem dito is that treatment plants are not designed to handle flood waters, they are only designed to handle the regular wastewater not including the flood water contamination, as i’ve said before no law is urging water treatment for flood, the law is only concerned to wastewater and not flood water kaya iiyak na lang talaga ang taga NCR hangga’t walang law vs flood